| Critic | Number Reviews | Positive |
| Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun-Times | 555 | 68% |
| Claudia Puig | USA Today | 457 | 43% |
| Avi Offer | NYC Movie Guru | 457 | 55% |
| Michael Phillips | Chicago Tribune | 428 | 49% |
| James Berardinelli | ReelViews | 410 | 46% |
| Peter Rainer | Christian Science Monitor | 389 | 60% |
| Elizabeth Weitzman | New York Daily News | 354 | 31% |
| Cole Smithey | ColeSmithey.com | 339 | 56% |
| Peter Travers | Rolling Stone | 331 | 56% |
| Joe Neumaier | New York Daily News | 330 | 22% |
 |
Title | Reviews | |
 |
Alice in Wonderland | 36% | (14/38) |
|
Brooklyn's Finest | 9% | (3/33) |
|
Harlan: In the Shado... | 60% | (3/5) |
|
Harlem Aria | 0% | (0/4) |
|
Title | Reviews | |
|
Shutter Island | 54% | (20/37) |
|
Alice in Wonderland | 36% | (14/38) |
|
Brooklyn's Finest | 9% | (3/33) |
|
Shutter Island | 54% | (20/37) |
|
Cop Out | 0% | (0/34) |
|
Avatar | 82% | (158/191) |